[Fire & Gas Systems] ๐Ÿ‘‰ My Wiring Class A|B|X| Selection Guide


The 3 Things You will learn today are as follows.

  1. What are the Wiring Classes (A,B,X) defined in NFPA 72
  2. The World's top Fire & Gas Standard.
  3. Habits that make you world class.

The Brain [๐Ÿง ]

Last week,

We learnt about

Addressable V/S Conventional F&G Communication System.

Nearly 4,000+ People shared that they found it valuable.

So thought to go a bit in-depth

On how to Wire them.


To Clear the Confusion.

The wiring methods that you will learn today (As per NFPA 72)

  • Class A
  • Class B
  • Class X

Can be used to Implement both Addressable or Conventional Communication System.

Addressable and Conventional describe:
How devices talk to the panel.
Class B, A and X describe:
How the wiring behaves when something goes wrong.

I am so excited to share this with you.

Let just begin the fun ....


#1 -Engineering Learning

Level 1: Class B Wiring

This is the simplest arrangement.

The cable leaves the panel.

Then passes via all devices.

It stops at the last device.

Advantages of Class A

โ•ฐโ”ˆโžค Less cable.

โ•ฐโ”ˆโžค Lower installation cost.

โ•ฐโ”ˆโžค Easier installation and maintenance.

If it is so good ?
Then why is it that NFPA mentions other wiring methods

The Super Danger Risk

If the cable is cut.

Devices beyond the cut are lost.


Example:

Imagine 10 detectors connected on one circuit.

If the cable breaks after Detector No. 3:

  • โœ… Detector 1 works.
  • โœ… Detector 2 works.
  • โœ… Detector 3 works.
  • โŒ Detector 4 to 10 are lost.

The panel reports a fault.

But a portion of your protection is gone.


Now What to do ?

If you know how we engineers think.

This is non-good.

We think smart ways to avoid fault.

Let's look at what engineers designing the NFPA standard though about this.


Level 2: Class A Wiring

So they created Class A.

The cable leaves the panel.

Passes through all devices.

Then returns back to the panel.
Creating a "loop".

Advantages

โ•ฐโ”ˆโžค Higher reliability.

โ•ฐโ”ˆโžค Better fault tolerance.

โ•ฐโ”ˆโžค Survives a single cable break.

Now imagine the cable gets cut.

The panel can "still communicate" with devices from the opposite direction.

Result:

  • Detection remains active.
  • Devices remain operational.
  • Panel reports a fault.

The system is damaged.

But it is still working.

That is the beauty of Class A.

BUT ......

A Big BUT ......

A Big Big BUT ......

What if ? (If there's a Short-Circuit)

What if the cable is not cut?

What if the conductors touch each other?

In simple words : called a short circuit.

A short circuit can be more severe than a simple cable break.

To solve this problem.

Engineers created Class X.

Think of Class X as:
Class A with body armor.
Class X uses short-circuit isolators.

These devices automatically separate the faulty section from the healthy section.

Result:

  • Survives a cable break.
  • Survives a short circuit.
  • Most devices continue operating.
  • Highest level of survivability possible.

This is why Class X is commonly used in critical facilities and below industries (Not for all but Critical Areas only).

  • Refineries.
  • LNG Plants.
  • Offshore Platforms.
  • Petrochemical Complexes.

Anywhere loss of detection cannot be tolerated.

I like to call it:

"The Special Forces version of Fire & Gas wiring.

Maybe the NFPA Engineering team was watching X-men hence they call this wiring Class X - Hope this makes it easier to remember" ๐Ÿ˜„

PS: Would you not want to select a Cable (For Fire & Gas) that works when there is an actual fire ?

If yes, then this Video here will help you learn the wiring selection.


The "Most Common" Mistake

Many Engineers think:
Addressable = Class A (Wrong)
Conventional = Class B (Wrong)

This is not correct

You can have:

  • Conventional with Class B Wiring
  • Conventional with Class A Wiring
  • Addressable with Class B Wiring
  • Addressable with Class A Wiring
  • Addressable with Class X Wiring

These are separate design decisions.


Which One Should You Select?

Class B

Best when:

  • Budget is important.
  • The system is relatively small.
  • Loss of a few devices during a fault is acceptable.

Class A

Best when:

  • Reliability is important.
  • Continuous detection is required.
  • A single cable cut should not disable the system.

Class X

Best when:

โžœ Maximum reliability is required.

โžœ Harsh industrial environments exist.

โžœ Process safety is critical and failure is catastrophic.

โžœ Loss of detection is unacceptable and the Plant budget allows it.


A Simple Rule to Remember

Addressable vs Conventional = How devices talk.

But Wiring class is how devices are connected.

  • Class B = A cable break can disable devices.
  • Class A = Survives one cable break and still functions.
  • Class X = Survives one cable break and one short circuit.

If you remember only these four lines.

You understand 90% of the topic.

PS: Would you not want to select a Cable (For Fire & Gas) that works when there is an actual fire ?

If yes, then this Video here will help you learn the wiring selection.


#2- Engineering Question

Corrosivity Class

If your outer environmental Corrosivity Class is lets say C5.

Will you select the same Corrosivity Class for Equipment's inside building as well ?

If you will select lower class ?

Then Client could question that the same Air (C5 corrosive air) will also come inside your control room.

How can you select low corrosivity class ?

How will you answer this question ?


#3 -Career Tipโ€‹

Resume PDF were in 1990's since there was no Internet.

People still assume PDF is sufficient for Job Openings.

The best Job opportunities are not in newspapers anymore.

Your LinkedIn profile is your "New Resume".
Update your LinkedIn Bio like a Professional Engineer.

This is very under-rated.

But trust me...... You will reap the fruits in future.

The People from Exxon / Shell / Technip etc have always reached out to me on LinkedIn and never via Job Portal.

Your linkedin presence matters.


#4 - Your Feedback

How was todays email lesson?

Reply "1" - Found Super Valuable

Reply "2" - Somewhat valuable

Reply "3" - Needs Improvement


Until next week,

Happy Learning and Keep Smiling.

โ€‹Asad Shaikhโ€‹

Your super passionate Instrumentation Friend!!

See you next Week!

โ€‹www.Asad-Shaikh.comโ€‹

PS : Here is the video to learn the Wiring Selection (Especially if you want your Fire and Gas Cable to work in Actual Fire)

LBS Road , Mumbai, Maharashtra 400086
โ€‹Unsubscribe ยท Preferencesโ€‹

Asad Shaikh

I'm a youtuber and educator who loves to talk about Instrumentation and Control Engineering. Subscribe and join over 10,000+ newsletter readers every week!

Read more from Asad Shaikh
person holding tool during daytime

๐Ÿ‘‰ " Three Times Better (Engineer) " The 3 Things You will learn are as follows. โ€ข My Flowmeter selection Algorithm. โ€ข How to Calculate Orifice Straight Length. โ€ข How to handle things (You have not done before) #1 -Engineering Question Hello Anti-Copy Paste Engineer, In my career, I have been part of 10,000+ Flowmeters Selection process and today's article is a summary of my entire experience. Below is a bullet point summary, but if you need a detailed PDF summary of Flowmeter Selection (With...

person holding tool during daytime

๐Ÿ‘‰ " Three Times Better (Engineer) " The 3 Things You will learn are as follows. โ€ข The 14 Timeless Rules in "Level Sketch". โ€ข The best Standard for Level Instrumentation. โ€ข Get your shoes "Dirty". #1 -Engineering Question Hello Anti-Copy Paste Engineer, I have made and checked more than 10,000+ Level Sketches in my career and today's article is a summary of my entire experience. Below is a bullet point summary, but if you need a detailed PDF summary of Level Sketch for future reference. Then...

person holding tool during daytime

The 3 Things You will learn today are as follows. The 9 M.A.S.T. Solution in valves. ISO Leakage Standard. You don't need a High IQ to succeed. I know today's email slightly late But trust me. You will find the efforts put into it, highly valuable. So, let's start. The Weakest Link [๐Ÿ”—] All automated valves have a stem. The actuator provides the Torque. The stem transmits this torque. But every stem has a breaking point. MAST- This is the Limit It Stands for M - Maximum A - Allowable S - Stem...